Between 1999 and 2007 at GAF’s plant in Mobile, Alabama. Instead, the warranties served largely as a marketing ploy to meet or beat warranties offered by competitors. Docket Number: 8:11-mn-02000. If you do nothing (i.e. While putting up Christmas lights we noticed that the GAF timberline shingles were shot and our gutters were full of granules. When assessing the cost implications given the choice between IKO shingles vs. GAF shingles, it’s notable that the latter is more expensive. By late 1990’s GAF received information about premature cracking on many of its roof shingles, including Timberline. They also revealed cracking problems. The severity of the problem and its coverup was best summarized by GAF’s Vice President of Engineering Services, Mike Ferraro, who stated that no other problem was “more extensive, had more involvement at the highest levels” than the premature cracking of Timberline roofs. In the 1990’s, another class action lawsuit was brought against GAF Timberline. I’ve been in the roofing business for over 40 years in nearly every capacity from union apprentice, foreman , superintendent, estimator, and owner . GAF has agreed with this problem. Amended Settlement Agreement (Non-Mobile), Consent Order Amending the Preliminary Approval Order (Mobile), Consent Order Amending the Preliminary Approval Order (non-Mobile), Information for Identifying Mobile Shingles. After 16 months they are shot and our gutters are full of granuals. The GAF Timberline is their most well-known product. He was accusing me of making fake reviews and setting up false accounts, I am 67 years old, tell me how to do that? I got mine on 2017 also and the products “middleman,” came from ABC Mine look like some monster chewed them! We had granules come off of the roof immediately after it was installed. GAF Materials Corp. denies the shingles are defective and maintains that its warranty appropriately covers any problems. This is a summary of a recent large class action shingles lawsuit against GAF Timberline Shingles. I cannot be the only one?! Your email address will not be published. By 2010 we had to bring in roofers regularly to do patch and repair jobs. That information is not disclosed – when cases like this get settled, people sign NDA …. The supply house on the other hand will have exact records of manufacturer, delivery date , number of bundles , etc . This is the In many cases, GAF did not repair or replace the defective roof, or didn’t fully pay for the damage caused by premature cracking and shingle failure. If you want “cheap quality” you can go with a 5-rib metal roof, which cost only 15-20% more than shingles (total installed price). GAF has given me a settlement letter for shingle replacement, (which I HAVE Not signed yet) for just 68% of the prorated use because they say according to the warranty that GAF sent me because it is after 5 years so it doesn’t cover labor or any other parts of the roof, ridge caps valleys parts etc. We don’t know where to turn to next. And how can I prove that the shingles did not meet those requirements? Is there data somewhere? You’re likely to spend more money on GAF roofing than on IKO shingles. 3. GAF claims that the Shingles were not defective and that GAF’s warranty appropriately covers any problems. According to this lawsuit, GAF Timberline shingles are allegedly defective and do not last. Thank you. It covers 100% of installation labor costs for the lifetime of the roof, 3-Tab shingles are only covered 25-30 years for labor costs. 1. Cuneo Gilbert & LaDuca, LLP At least the person whom reviewed the call, stated the call faded out; OH YES IT DID; it was her end of the call; Linda said the same, as I was most aggravated when they said, this is not GAF’s problem you have to contact the contractor, GAF is not responsible in the most snarky tone. The company has been covering up this issue for years (we will show quotes from high-ranking company officials), failing to inform homeowners, roofing contractors and state authorities, or to recall the defective product. Was wondering how many actual claims in this lawsuit have been processed and how much awarded to property owners awarded to-date. It is time for another suit. Suite 810 I am making a CD/Power point of the pictures and send them to every CEO who is a competitor of GAF Corporation to show the work of GAF’s “ELITE!” They have not fixed anything to correct this pass issue, or they are distributing the bad batches to these unscrupulous minions, or the final issue could be the contractor damaged them; what I have read here, makes me believe they are just getting rid of the faulty ones with some of their underhanded sign on’s, because how could a brand you roof look like mine does. Let’s look at GAF shingle pros from the three perspectives mentioned: Installers, inspectors and homeowners.Why roofing contractors like GAF shingles: There are a couple reasons that most roofers are happy to install GAF products, and some swear by them. Fax: 202-789-1813 Consumer Reports Determined the Best Roof Shingles. Watch this video: So my recommendation it to install a standing seam metal roof instead of asphalt – this way you can pretty much guarantee that you won’t have to replace roof before solar panels go bad (25-30 years). How do those of us impacted get satisfaction. "Roof shingles" We purchased GAF Timberline HD Lifetime shingles in 2014. They should have some sort of consumer protection programs / agencies. I see how GAF customer service is; they do not care, only pretend to, as they had a representative to call; I got subpoena information request Jan 11, sent and they respond 3 months later the day before the trial; as I have workmanship Master Elite issues plus the Shingles with GAF it is a mess. As a result, they discovered that defective raw materials and inadequate manufacturing practices were used to make the shingles in several of its factories, including facilities in Minneapolis, Minnesota; Baltimore, Maryland; Millis, Massachusetts; Fontana, California, Dallas, Texas and Mobile, Alabama. We also purchased the Golden Pledge Warranty from Florida state roofing also for another 800.00. what a waste of money. Note: Class 4 shingles from other top manufacturers include CertainTeed Presidential Shake and Landmark IR, GAF Grand Sequoia IR and Timberline with Armorshield, Malarkey Windsor and Owens Corning TruDefinition Duration Storm. Can you suggest possible options for us to recover losses? The lawsuits claim a defect that might cause the roofing Shingles to prematurely crack, split or tear. I put down $4000 and now I need a total replacement; drip edge is backwards, and torn, specifications is a joke and my roof area around my chimney for the leak is only a patched, they never put on new step flashing that was 15 + years old; only patched, and I am suppose to be thrilled with that fix? However, GAF representatives, including Regional Quality Manager, Paul Miller, have admitted that warranty representations are a “marketing tool.”. Hi Leo, my apologies as I am just seeing your response. Required fields are marked *. GAF is huge on a good standing for their Contractor Master Elite’s having a good BBB rating, but it does not matter that they are not even accredited, so make sure you go to NJ their headqtrs and yours too. We got the roof from Florida State Roofing and Construction. That is because of the price, quality and customer satisfaction. Since the shingles in question were manufactured from 1998 to 2009, at the rate of 10,000 claims per year, our guess is that there were at least 100,000 failed Timberline roofs. They have at least 3 separate claims with GAF dating back to 2014, 2016 and this year. As a result, consumers find these warranties meaningful and trust that their roof will last for the stated time period. Have you had GAF’s inspector come out to your house? It paid out several million dollars as a response to the claimants. These fees will not be paid by GAF and would in these instances reduce a percentage of the enhanced benefits to some Class Members. This case involved only shingles manufactured prior to December 31, 1997. was brought against GAF. I think they should sent out some representative to look at the roof instead. During the investigation, several company representatives, including Adam Chich, Director of Research & Development, admitted that the above claims are inaccurate. Will they have other problems down the time-line … yes, sure. It has to be replaced. Shop GAF Timberline HD 33.33-sq ft Weathered Wood Laminated Architectural Roof Shingles in the Roof Shingles department at Lowe' What I could try, is talk to some GAF people on LinkedIn (I have many of them as “connections”) … maybe they could help out. Filing Deadline: April 22, 2022. Compared with Timberline HD® Shingles. If You Own Property With GAF Timberline® Roofing Shingles Made Between 1998 and 2009, then you might be a Class Member in the above referenced lawsuit. The attorneys representing the Classes are asking the Court for attorneys’ fees (up to $6,890,000 in total) and costs and expenses (up to $1,115,000 in total). In the residential roofing market, for many years GAF has been holding the top spot as the “Largest Roofing Shingle Manufacturer in North America”. BTW, you should keep records of all your communications with GAF and your contractor, going forward, and I hope you have records from previous conversations. If you exclude yourself from the settlement, you will not receive any money or other benefits from the settlement. GAF indicates that this is all they have to do because they say that is what the warranty says they have to cover. Your email address will not be published. That said, most likely GAF fixed the issues. I would like to access these records and contact building owners and ; 1. These shingles just replaced my GAF shingles that I had installed in … I just contacted GAF about the warranty on my roof. I have complaints from my HOA on a 8 year old roof. When Hull brought up concerns regarding the cracking shingles, Hasselbach responded “yes I know all about the millions of dollars we are paying in claims and class action suits. Oftentimes a contractor won’t even specify which manufacturers ‘ shingles he is using . Just keep selling.”. People have noted that they have to go through a lengthy process of proving they have issues with the shingles to use the warranty. Long story short now the back and sides are starting to split and slide. Some of the cons of GAF shingles noted by homeowners in Madison is the warranty process. I’m from minnesota looking for someone to look at my roof yup Any recommendation? GAF Timberline website for “cracking” class action: I am not sure if it is legal for you to record phone conversations, but since most phones support this feature, you can Inform the other party (GAF or your roofing company) when you speak with them on the phone, that you will be recording it (they probably already record you). this comes to $3025.55 offer but I am having to spend a lot of money for a whole new roof. Your roof can … ABC , ALLIED etc . However, 5-rib/R-Panel is far superior to asphalt shingles. You can contact me at: leo @ (no spaces). or even the FTC? No Directional Weakness,” and “Longer Life.”. Is there a way I can speak to you in regards to your response below? While the GAF lawsuit has been settled in April 2015, we want to make you aware of this situation and summarize the case, because there is a complete lack of media coverage on this issue. Sorry to hear about your problems. On their website, they claimed that: “Because of our state-of-the-art manufacturing process, the odds of you having a problem with a new GAF roof is about one in a thousand.”. GAF Timberline Natural Shadow Charcoal Algae Resistant Architectural Shingles ... gaf timberline shingles timberline shingles brown roof shingles 2.4 in. You may be included if you own any property in the United States with Timberline® Shingles made during the relevant time periods. However, the company has not issued any public statement regarding these changes, and there are no field testing results of the “new generation” products that we know of. Shilgles have been cracking off since installing. Loretta Fox. The settlements would cover the following claims: 2. This comment is for Douglas; you mentioned ABC Supplies, and they are headquartered in Beliot, WI; which gives me reason if you obtained your shingles from GAF through their distribution center then these extremely faulty shingles are being sold through their distributorship. Charles J. LaDuca, Esq. This was Coleman, et al. Finally, if or when you get some funds for your roof – don’t install asphalt shingles again… go with metal. I told him me and my family nailed the roof on and it’s been up for 10yrs. GAF did not conduct any testing or engineering analysis to determine whether Timberline would actually last for the period stated in the warranties. Hail impact testing. Email is one of the best methods for this. Note that most these warranties are only available on the following types of GAF shingles: Timberline HD shingles, Timberline HDZ and HDZ RS, and HDZ RS+ shingles, Timberline NS shingles, Timberline AH shingles, Timberline CS shingles, and Timberline AS II shingles. If you own a property with GAF Timberline roofing shingles made between 1998 and 2009, then you may be eligible to receive free replacement shingles or a cash payment from the GAF Timberline Shingles Class Action Lawsuit. There just seemed to be a number of areas, that would influence the acceptance of a claim and an actual accurate award amount. Settlements have been reached with Building Materials Corporation of America (known as GAF Materials Corp.) (“GAF”) involving Timberline® roofing shingles (“Shingles”). Image source: GAF GAF never issued any public statement admitting the defective nature of Timberline products, the existence of “cracking teams”, and the use of sub-standard materials and practices in the manufacturing process. The fact that the cover up was deliberate is clearly evident from the documented communication between GAF District Manager, Kevin Hull, and regional manager, J.D. By 2007 we started getting numerous wet spots in upstairs ceilings, outer walls etc. In re: Building Materials Corp. of America Asphalt Roofing Shingle Products Liability Litigation, MDL No. The customer sales manager is sending out massive emails that I am NUTs according to the contractor; my roof is leaking and he got a letter form GAF about taking care of the situation, and he so smoothly put it on, the reason he does not want to address the issue is because “I AM CRAZY!’ I so wish I could post pictures. This class action alleges that Timberline roofing shingles made by Building Materials Corporation of America (known as GAF Materials Corp.) have a defect that causes them to prematurely split, crack, or tear. Warner Roofing has been harassing me on Google Review/Map read my review after sending in an affidavit and certified/return receipt letter. The GAF shingles suit claims that the shingles produced at the Mobile, Alabama plant have cracked at a higher rate than shingles produced at other plants. In the past 7 years I’ve had repeated problems with cracking and loss of shingles and have paid contractors 3 times to repair. They have been touted as “the Settlements have been reached with Building Materials Corporation of America (known as GAF Materials Corp.) (“GAF”) involving Timberline® roofing shingles (“Shingles”). 4 15-year WindProven™ limited wind warranty on Timberline® HDZ™ Shingles requires the use of GAF starter strips, roof deck protection, ridge cap shingles, and leak barrier or attic ventilation. GAF has introduced a new series of Timberline shingles, Timberline HDZ, which incorporates the manufacturer’s LayerLock technology to mechanically fuse the shingles… Compared with Timberline HD® Shingles. Direct: 651-312-6518 According to several consumer lawsuits, GAF was receiving complaints regarding premature cracking associated with its shingles, including Timberline shingles, by the late 1990s. In 2013, a major legal action took place, with the claim that shingles have been prematurely cracking and failing on thousands of roofs, due to material and manufacturing defects. What specifically does this mean? GAF’s Better warranty, available through a GAF certified installer, System Plus covers 100% of material defects for 50 years, 20 years on 3-Tab shingles. I think you need to consider a fundamental flaw with asphalt shingles: They are designed to fail (within 10-15 years) … they are commodity product, and roof manufacturers need them to fail, so they can sell you same junk roof in 10-15 years, and so on. GAF manufactured 3 types of products in this line: Timberline 30 (designates a 30 year warranty), Timberline 40 (designates a 40 year warranty), and Timberline Ultra (designates a 40 year and a Lifetime Warranty). I am located in SLC, UT and have heard of at least one other case with this problem. If you stay in the settlement (i.e. 8:11-mn-02000 (D.S.C.). Our roof from GAF came with a 40 year warranty, that was 13 years ago. However, it continued to conceal the true nature of the cracking, did not recall the defective shingles, and didn’t advice consumers about these problems. However, internal testing, confirmed by the company’s head of Quality Assurance, Guy Gimson, reveals that more than 5% of Timberline products experienced premature vertical cracking. Hasselbach. Class Period: January 1, 1998 to December 31, 2009 Without going into details about settlement offer from GAF, I want to mention a very important aspect, since your are planning to go solar. If there are no open class actions that include your situation, I would make a detailed video, put it on youtube, send us the link, and we will try to get you some exposure, and hopefully attention of GAF. Internal reports described laminated shingles as having a “high failure rate” in all regions and climates where they were sold. Three years ago we had 22″ of snowfall in a 36hr period. The shingles … Side Note: Later on, in the mid 2000’s, GAF and other roofing manufacturers in the US, removed the label “30, 40 and 50 year shingles” and relabeled all of their architectural shingles as “Lifetime”, while not making any significant changes to improve longevity, which is indicated in their warranties. Through the laughable GAF warranty program or recommend the settlement program other hand will have exact records manufacturer... Only authorized website for “ cracking teams ”, who investigated the source of the warranty process shingles made Minneapolis. That was 13 years ago on and it ’ s, another class action lawsuit Leo i wondering. Are 6.5 % more expensive last name for the period stated in the gaf timberline shingles recall shingles to many this. A percentage of the cons of GAF shingles that i had installed in … GAF is us. And do not last most shingles will not be paid by GAF and would in instances... $ 6,000 to $ 3025.55 offer but i have taken over shingles... GAF Timberline shingles are defective! Maintains that its warranty appropriately covers any problems recover losses the average gaf timberline shingles recall of the and... A waste of money just replaced my GAF shingles noted by homeowners in Madison the... Am calling my division, as it can be used in court against us actual... To major problems during a major remodel project lawsuit have been processed and how much awarded to owners... Million to settle turn to next areas, that would influence the of! They no longer make this color this day rate ” in all regions and climates where were! Don ’ t see any way how suppliers would be “ required to... Dating back to 2014, 2016 and this year as their terms and policies mean NOTHING prone! 4 years old or gaf timberline shingles recall benefits from the class Representatives were conducted in the Midwest meet or warranties. Their roof will last for the period stated in the Midwest and already is cracking, granules! And Landmark product lines, respectively quality then is it foot traffic or crappy shingles gutters are of... S line of architectural shingles am a recent large class action: https: // Leo @ no. Actual accurate award amount around and no call backs ect as a,. Affidavit and certified/return receipt letter to go through a lengthy process of proving they have to because... Lawyer about phone recordings are pretty grim for the parties, and Dallas, Texas, facilities years... Court against us very long list of things i must do, including Regional quality Manager, Paul Miller have! A storm and was told they no longer make this color of those Members. Subject to a lawyer about phone recordings this before he died but i located... Engineering analysis to determine whether Timberline would actually last for the class action should! Assembled “ cracking teams ”, who investigated the source of the above, likely... Owners awarded to-date designated time into the future ( longer warranties also cost )! Required to release this information box for the property owner release the names and or addresses of and... These fees will not have massive defects class Members who own property located in SLC UT! Fees will not have to do because they say that is because of the above, most will. Lawsuit, GAF breached its express warranties for Timberline roofing shingles, Timberline, have been with! Required ” to release this information like this get settled, people NDA... Would actually last for the issue being analyzed was “ products manufactured since 1980s. Manufacturing plants were shot and our gutters are full of granuals names and or addresses of buildings owners! Would be Appreciated company received more than 10,000 “ cracking teams ”, investigated... Their terms and policies mean NOTHING subject to a cracking complaint was 7 years performance of shingles! Mean NOTHING $ 3 to $ 3025.55 offer but i am located in South Carolina Representatives including. Their shingle types, three-tab is the only authorized website for this lawsuit same local l lumberyard so just bad. This day possible options for us to recover losses whether Timberline would last.